Answer:
Whether a person is a sinner or not should not be the deciding
factor in giving him or her Zakāh or charity. In other words, being a sinner
does not disqualify someone from being a recipient of charity. It is his or
her state of being needy and afflicted with trouble that should be the basic
factor in making such a decision. Once the decision is made on this basis,
other factors such as this can, of course, play a supportive role.
Moreover, letting sinners suffer is certainly not the right way to deal with
such people. I think that such people need to be helped both monetarily and
spiritually. Also, in this regard the real thing is the attitude adopted
after sinning: One cannot lead a sinless life. It is humanly impossible. One
is required to repent and ask the Almighty’s pardon when he falls prey to
sins.
People who have sinned need more sympathy and compassion. It is towards them
that one’s efforts of reformation should be more focused. As the Prophet
Jesus (sws) has beautifully put it:
…It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. But go and learn
what this means. I desire mercy not sacrifice. For I have come not to call
the righteous, but sinners. (Matthew, 9:12-3) |