Answer: Notwithstanding the
fact that many scholars of this Ummah believe that blasphemy should be
punished by death, I am afraid that this crime was not made punishable by
death either through the Holy Qur’ān or the Sunnah. No doubt, it is a wicked
crime and thus indeed is contemptuous to humanity as well. Yet, it was never
made punishable by death through the two fundamental sources of Islam. There
has indeed been much hullabaloo over it in the last couple of centuries.
However, we must know that Allah has explicitly prohibited killing of any
human being except for two reasons: a court of law may deliver capital
punishment to an intentional murderer or someone guilty of spreading anarchy
in society. Apart from these two situations, any killing would be equivalent
to slaughtering all of mankind. The Holy Qur’ān reads:
He who killed a human being
without the latter being guilty of killing another or of spreading anarchy
in the land, should be looked upon as if he killed all of mankind. (5:32)
I therefore maintain that
the Holy Qur’ān itself stands against this sort of punishment. The proper
way to deal with such sacrilegious acts is to ignore them. We must remain
patient and let the petty issues die their own death. I am suggesting this
because I believe any stirring from our side would only give a new life to
the current of craziness. The Lord Himself advises the Prophet (sws) to
adopt the same approach regarding the daggers of rebuke and scoff which are
hurled towards him. He consoles the Prophet (sws) that he should rest
assured that Allah will defend him and his scoffers will meet a grievous
penalty for their untoward attitude. The Holy Qur’ān records:
And incline not the
disbelievers and the hypocrites. Disregard their noxious talk, and put your
trust in Allah, Allah is sufficient as trustee. (33:48)
So proclaim that which you
are commanded, and withdraw from the idolaters. We do defend you from the
scoffers who set some other gods along with Allah. But they will come to
know. Well know We that your bosom is at times oppressed by what they say.
But hymn the praise of your Lord, and be of those who make prostration [unto
Him]. And serve your Lord till the inevitable come to you. (15:94-9)
|