| Answer: * The
Tarāwīh prayer is actually the Tahajjud prayer that was held obligatory for the
Holy Prophet (sws) and optional for the rest of the Muslims. The Prophet (sws)
would always offer the prayer at home. But once he happened to offer it in the
mosque. However, he never offered this prayer with ‘Ishā; rather at its
prescribed time after midnight. Once, during a Ramadan, some Companions saw the
Holy Prophet (sws) praying in the mosque at night and they joined him. The
second night the Prophet (sws) again appeared in the mosque and this time the
number of the Companions increased as they had learnt that the Prophet (sws)
came to the mosque to offer Tahajjud the previous night; they in their earnest
efforts to follow the Holy Prophet (sws) joined him in his prayer. The same
happened on the third night. But the Holy Prophet (sws) did not come to pray on
the fourth night. The reason being that he had noticed that the people started
praying the Tahajjud in the mosque and he feared that it might be perceived as
obligatory like the other five prayers.
Another important point in this regard is that the Prophet
(sws) had allowed Muslims to offer this prayer before going to bed if they
thought that it would be difficult for them to offer it at its prescribed time.
He had said:
Whoever among you fears that he would not be able to
rise during the last part of the night (for Tahajjud) he ought to pray an odd
number of Rak‘ats before going to bed. However, those who are sure that they
would be able to get up at that time must pray an odd number of Rak‘ats then as
the recitation during the last part of the night best affords concentration and
therefore bears excellence. (Muslim, No: 163)
As we have reached the conclusion that Tarāwīh is in fact
Tahajjud prayer, we now proceed to ascertain the number of the Rak‘at. The
following narrative is the most comprehensive on the issue:
Abū Salāmah b. ‘Abd al-Rahmān narrates that I asked
‘Ā’ishah, wife of the Prophet (sws): ‘How did the Apostle of Allah (sws) pray
during Ramadan?’ She replied: ‘The Apostle of Allah (sws) did not pray more than
eleven Rak‘ats during Ramadan and other than Ramadan. He would pray four Rak‘ats.
Do not ask about their elegance and length! He would then pray four Rak‘ats. Do
not ask about their elegance and length! Then he would pray three Rak‘ats’. (Bukhārī:
No. 1147)
Although some other narratives tell us that he sometimes
prayed thirteen Rak‘ats but we believe that these two Rak‘ats had been added in
the same way as he would add two during other obligatory prayers, for example
Maghrib, which we generally call Nafl. It should be kept in mind that Tahajjud
is obligatory for the Prophet (sws) in contrast to other Muslims.
As for the decision of the Caliph Umar (rta), it needs to
be appreciated that he only organized the Companions who were reciting the
Qur’ān in their individual prayers in the mosque— he only intended to rectify
the state of chaos in which no one could know who was reciting what. He however
did not participate in the prayer himself and preferred to offer the prayer at
its prescribed time. This is manifest from his remark as recorded in the
well-known narrative about the Tarāwīh that ‘How blessed is the act they have
left for the act they are performing!’
We think that a person can go on offering the Tarāwīh in
the present form as it affords him an opportunity to recite and listen to the
Qur’ān. You therefore should go on praying all through Ramadan. However, it
would be an unfounded claim to say that the prayer in question must essentially
be offered with the ‘Ishā prayer; the befitting way is to offer the Tahajjud at
the prescribed time, which should always be stressed upon.
|